Monday, June 24, 2013

Discovery Writing and the Alpha Reader

In a previous post, I discussed why the “Go! Go! Go!” approach for writers may not make the most sense for discovery writers. Discovery writers are discovering their story as they write, and I concluded that finishing a draft without revising could lead to a lot of wasted time and energy. Revising my opening chapters has definitely helped me make sure I'm heading forward on solid ground, hopefully saving me from writing a draft that I will end up throwing away.

Another important part of my process is the alpha reader, someone who reads my chapters before I complete the entire draft. Alpha readers either reassure me that my beginning is solid, or they advise me that I'm taking a wrong turn. I had two alpha readers for SKY MAHAL and they both provided me with valuable guidance that made a huge difference in how the book turned out.

If you're worried about showing people your first draft, you're not alone. I actually never show my alpha readers my first draft of anything. I tend to revise the things that most egregiously need work before asking my alpha readers to step in and give me direction. With my last novel, I can't remember how many times I revised my opening chapter. But eventually I reached an impasse, where I had no idea if what I've just written is complete garbage or not. That's when my alpha readers stepped in.

Requirements of an alpha reader:
  1. Must be able to read your work in progress and truly recognize that it is a work in progress and therefore ignore your rough prose
  2. Must have a strong understanding of story and be able to articulate why you're headed in the wrong direction (e.g. you're revealing too much too fast, or not enough)
  3. Is generally just plain fabulous :)

In other words, your alphas have to be more sophisticated readers than your average beta. A beta reads a mostly polished draft and only needs to be able to tell you whether they were engaged or not, and at which parts. An alpha is much more of a partner in your story creation process, someone who can give you ideas on how to get unstuck, how to climb out of a giant plot hole, how to make your love interest more compelling, etc. At the very least, an alpha should recognize these problems and voice them before you proceed. Your alphas might be just one or two close friends, or it might be an entire critique group. The important part is that they can intervene at an early stage (hopefully without breaking your will to live!).

With SKY MAHAL, my first draft was pretty much useless. With the second(ish) draft, I gave my alphas 3-5 chapters at a time. I revised those chunks myself before handing them over, so there weren't serious flaws that I knew I had to change. I found that my two alpha readers pointed out vastly different things. One was very concerned about character interactions and making my main character likeable. The other pointed out when I was losing suspense or giving away too many of my villain's motives. Both were completely awesome and saved me from wasting time.

The best case scenario is that your alpha readers tell you you're basically on the right track. Fantastic! You can go forward with some confidence. Otherwise, you revise. And that can be frustrating if you're sick of a chapter that isn't working. Occasionally, my alphas would have so many issues with a chapter, I would have to rewrite it, show it to them, and then rewrite it again. It was slow in the first 1/3 of my manuscript, but I ended up being able to write the remaining 2/3 much faster as a result. I had large sections that hardly needed any revising at all. Thank you alphas!

So tell me, do you use alphas? Or do you guard your early drafts tightly?

6 comments:

  1. I tend to avoid outside feedback until I've completed the second draft. My first drafts I keep to myself, and my second drafts are still relatively rough, but as you said, I know (or at least, I'm pretty confident) that I don't have any enormous, glaring problems. From there, I alternate with betas until I'm happy with it. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Makes sense! It's great if you can make it through 2 drafts without having a major failure of confidence. I aspire to that!

      Delete
  2. I use alpha readers. Those are pretty trusted readers who know my process and aren't wasting time pointing out grammatical or punctuation errors. I found them through trial and error though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep, finding great alphas is hard. But we sure appreciate them when we do!

      Delete
  3. I've always used an Alpha, and she's be very helpful, but I recently decided to try not letting anyone read my first draft for my next project. I've had more than one person tell me know that the work is stronger if you don't let anyone sway you until your second draft. I've never tried it that way, so I thought I'd give it a shot. Has anyone tried both ways?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep, and I've had mixed experiences. With a previous novel, I didn't show it to anyone until it was nearly polished. However, that one had a simpler storyline that I was able to write quickly and easily. I definitely think it depends on your needs as you progress. If you feel you're headed in the right direction, keep at it!

      Delete